How to Prepare Your CPG Leadership Team for the New Year

Before setting next year's revenue goals, a growing CPG company should evaluate whether its leadership team has the capabilities and capacity to deliver them.

A new year often brings ambitious plans: new retail accounts, product launches, geographic expansion, fundraising, increased headcount, or higher revenue targets. But growth plans are only as strong as the leadership team responsible for executing them.

For CPG companies, the end of the year is an opportunity to step back and ask an important question:

Is our leadership team built for where the business is going, not just where it is today?

1. Review What This Year Exposed

Before planning for next year, look at what actually happened this year.

Growth often exposes leadership gaps that aren't obvious when the business is operating at a smaller scale. Peak seasons, new channels, product launches, hiring, and operational challenges can all reveal where the organization is struggling.

Ask:

  • What repeatedly became a bottleneck?

  • Where did decisions slow down?

  • What problems kept coming back?

  • Which functions struggled to keep up with growth?

  • Where did teams have difficulty working together?

  • What strategic initiatives didn't get implemented?

  • What did the founder or CEO have to personally step in and solve?

  • Which responsibilities became significantly more complex?

These aren't just operational questions. They're signals about whether the leadership structure is keeping pace with the business.

For example, if the founder repeatedly had to step in to resolve supply chain issues, manage key retail relationships, or make decisions across multiple departments, the issue may not simply be workload. It may indicate that the company needs additional executive ownership.

As discussed in What Black Friday Reveals About Your CPG Leadership Team, periods of peak pressure can make leadership gaps particularly visible.

2. Evaluate Each Executive's Scope

Once you've identified the challenges from the past year, look at how responsibilities are currently distributed.

Ask of each executive:

  • What does this person currently own?

  • Has their scope expanded significantly?

  • Are they managing functions outside their original expertise?

  • Are they spending too much time on tactical work?

  • Do they have enough resources beneath them?

  • Are they making decisions they should own—or decisions that belong elsewhere?

  • What will their role look like if the company grows another 25% or 50%?

It's common for executive responsibilities to expand naturally as a company grows.

A leader who successfully managed one function at an earlier stage may eventually be responsible for several teams, channels, or strategic priorities.

That doesn't necessarily mean the executive needs to be replaced. It may mean the role needs to be redesigned, additional support needs to be added, or another executive needs to take ownership of a growing area.

The goal is to determine whether each leader has a realistic scope for the next stage of the business.

3. Identify Leadership Gaps

Next, separate problems that can be solved through better processes or resources from problems that require additional leadership capability.

A leadership gap exists when the organization lacks the experience, expertise, or ownership needed to accomplish something important.

For a growing CPG company, that could mean:

  • No senior leader owns commercial growth

  • The founder still owns too many operational decisions

  • Financial complexity has outgrown the current finance team

  • Supply chain has become significantly more complex

  • A new retail channel requires expertise the current team doesn't have

  • The company is entering a new market without an experienced leader

  • A major strategic initiative has no clear executive owner

Use How to Identify Leadership Gaps in a Growing Consumer Brand to evaluate where the organization may need additional leadership capacity.

Importantly, not every gap means you need to hire a C-suite executive.

Sometimes the answer is promoting an existing leader, expanding a team, hiring a director or VP, or clarifying ownership.

The question is: What capability does the business need that it doesn't currently have?

4. Look at the Next 12–24 Months

Your leadership team should be evaluated against the company's future plans, not just its current size.

Look at the major initiatives on the roadmap for 2027 and beyond.

Is the company planning to:

  • Enter new retail channels?

  • Launch significant new products?

  • Expand into new geographies?

  • Increase manufacturing capacity?

  • Grow its DTC business?

  • Raise capital?

  • Pursue an acquisition?

  • Significantly increase headcount?

  • Expand internationally?

  • Build a more sophisticated ecommerce or commercial organization?

  • Move from founder-led operations to a more formal management structure?

Each initiative creates different leadership requirements.

A company planning to double its retail footprint may need different commercial and operational expertise than a company focused on launching a new product portfolio through DTC.

This is why executive planning shouldn't happen separately from business planning.

Your growth strategy should inform your leadership strategy.

5. Determine Which Leadership Hires Need to Happen First

Once you've identified the capabilities the business needs, determine which leadership gaps are most urgent.

You probably don't need to hire every missing executive at once.

Instead, consider: Which leadership gap is currently creating the biggest constraint on growth?

Then ask: Which hire would unlock the next stage of the business?

For one company, that might be a VP of Sales. For another, it might be a CFO. For another, it could be a COO who can take operational responsibility away from the founder.

This is especially important for founder-led companies with limited resources. Building an executive team is often a staged process.

If you're evaluating where to start, see What Executive Should a Founder Hire First When Scaling a Consumer Brand?.

You can also use What Executive Roles Does a Growing CPG Brand Need? as a broader framework for evaluating the functions your company may eventually need.

6. Build the Executive Hiring Roadmap

Not every leadership hire needs to happen in January.

Once you've identified the roles you'll eventually need, map them against the company's growth plans.

For example:

Q1→Hire the executive addressing the most immediate growth constraint

Q2→Add leadership needed for a planned channel, product, or operational expansion

Q3→Evaluate whether additional functional leadership is needed

Q4→Plan the next stage of the executive team


The exact timing will depend on the company.

What matters is avoiding reactive hiring.

If you know a major retail expansion is planned for the second half of the year, waiting until the expansion is already underway to begin looking for the executive who will lead it can create unnecessary pressure.

Executive searches also take time. Senior candidates may not be actively looking, and the right candidate may need to be identified and recruited well before the company feels an immediate crisis.

That makes leadership planning an important part of annual business planning—not something to revisit only after a role becomes urgent.

7. Align the Leadership Team Around the Growth Plan

Finally, make sure the leadership team understands what the company is trying to accomplish and what will be required from each leader.

This is where leadership capacity becomes important.

The question isn't simply: Do we have the right people?

It's: Does the current team have enough capacity to accomplish everything we're asking the business to do?

A leadership team can have talented executives and still be overextended.

For example, your leadership team may technically have someone responsible for sales, marketing, finance, and operations—but if each executive is already operating at maximum capacity, adding another major growth initiative may stretch the organization beyond what it can effectively execute.

As you plan for the new year, look at both capability and capacity.

Capability

Does the team have the expertise needed to achieve the plan?

Capacity

Does the team have enough time, resources, organizational support, and leadership bandwidth to actually execute it?

Both matter.

A new growth plan may require additional executive leadership even if the current team is performing well. The issue isn't necessarily that anyone is underperforming. The business may simply have become too complex for the existing leadership structure.

Turn Your 2027 Growth Plan Into a Leadership Plan

Annual planning often focuses heavily on revenue, distribution, product launches, margins, and other business goals.

But every one of those goals requires people to execute them.

Before finalizing your 2027 plan, ask:

  • What does the business need to accomplish?

  • What leadership capabilities will those goals require?

  • Where is the current team stretched?

  • Which executive roles need to evolve?

  • Which leadership gaps need to be addressed?

  • Which hires need to happen first?

  • What needs to happen in Q1 versus later in the year?

  • Does the current leadership team have enough capacity for the plan?

The answers can help turn an annual business plan into a leadership roadmap.

And if the answer to those questions points toward a new executive hire, it's worth starting the process before the role becomes urgent.

When to Start an Executive Search

One of the biggest advantages of identifying a leadership need during annual planning is that you can begin the search before the business is already feeling the consequences of the gap.

Senior executives are often not actively looking for a new role. Finding the right candidate can therefore require time, targeted outreach, and a search process built around the specific experience the company needs.

That means January doesn't necessarily need to be the starting point.

If your 2027 plan depends on a new executive being in place by Q2, Q3, or later in the year, the search may need to begin well before that deadline.

The earlier you identify the leadership requirement, the more thoughtfully you can define the role, build the candidate profile, and plan the transition.

For a broader look at the process, see How to Hire Executives for a Growing CPG Company: A Step-by-Step Guide.

How Fairfield Partners Helps Growing CPG Brands Plan for Their Next Stage

Building the right leadership team starts with understanding where the business is today, where it's going, and what leadership capabilities will be required to get there.

Fairfield Partners specializes in executive search for high-growth consumer brands, with experience across food, beverage, supplements, personal care, pet care, and other consumer products categories.

Fairfield Partners works with growing brands to identify and recruit senior leaders across critical functions, helping companies build leadership teams that can support their next stage of growth.

If your 2027 growth plan is likely to require new executive leadership, the end of the year is a valuable time to start defining what that team needs to look like.

The strongest time to identify a leadership gap is before it becomes a growth constraint.

Next
Next

How to Build a CPG Leadership Team That Can Scale